German automotive giants have taken a similar path in creating their compact crossovers. BMW and AUDI have veered away from the previous trend of constantly increasing the sizes of SUVs. The new versions of the CUV series have been downsized, making them something in between a classic crossover and a hatchback. Enthusiasts can witness the evolution of BMW X1 and AUDI Q3 with their own eyes.
Initially, the Bavarians released the powerful and brutal X5. Then, a more compact X3 joined the lineup. The series was logically completed with the X1 model.
A similar trend was observed at AUDI. Among the entire Q series, the third model appeared later than the others and received reduced dimensions.
Such a trend from the two well-known automakers is not accidental. Many drivers are opting for less powerful SUVs and crossovers, preferring more serene and agile models. These cars are cheaper to maintain, easier to park, but significantly lack in terms of off-road capabilities. However, both the BMW X1 and AUDI Q3 were designed exclusively for urban environments.
These vehicles can handle light off-road terrain, but expecting exceptional off-road performance from them is clearly not advisable. The compact crossover class is not suitable for fishing or hunting enthusiasts.
Exterior of BMW X1 and AUDI Q3
The BMW X1 was the first to hit the market. The compact five-seater crossover went into production in 2009. The initial models rolled off the assembly line in Leipzig. During development, the company's engineers used the base from the BMW 3 Series station wagon.
The exterior of the crossover fully adheres to the established concept by the Bavarian automaker. The car's aggression is enhanced by the unusual shape of the radiator grille, predatory LED headlights, and a robust front bumper. All body lines are crisp and sleek. This geometry immediately indicates decent speed characteristics and high maneuverability.
The car's design serves two purposes. It creates a unique appearance and improves the model's aerodynamic performance. Reduced air resistance was achieved through three techniques:
- reduced hood;
- specific angle of the rear window;
- high window line.
These factors reduce the impact of the oncoming airflow, resulting in faster acceleration for the car.
The rear of the Bavarian car is more subdued. The narrowed taillights add a bit of aggression to the model, but overall, the rear appearance is simpler. A small factory spoiler emphasizes the car's high dynamism.
Now, in the comparison between BMW X1 and AUDI Q3, it's time to analyze the direct competitor to the Bavarian. AUDI engineers developed their own compact SUV slightly later. The model went on sale in 2011. Currently, the car is manufactured in Germany, Spain, Brazil, and China.
Unlike other models in the Q series, the presented car has a modified front end. Manufacturers equipped the car with updated bi-xenon headlights, an enlarged radiator grille, and air intakes with a new design.
The optics and rear bumper were made more massive and aggressive. Overall, all the car's lines are smooth and sharp, indicating the urban «residence» of the vehicle and its speed characteristics.
To improve aerodynamic characteristics, AUDI made a small trick. Engineers tilted the car's roof from the front to the rear.
Dimensions
When comparing BMW X1 and AUDI Q3, it is necessary to analyze the dimensions of each model. In this case, it is impossible to unequivocally determine a winner. The length of the Audi Q3 is 4388 millimeters. The X1, on the other hand, has a similar parameter larger by 51 mm.
However, the Bavarian model is 10 mm narrower. The X1 is taller than its competitor by 8 mm. The cars are quite comparable to each other, so it's impossible to name a clear leader in this comparison.
BMW also has a special extended version, the X1 L. These cars are exclusively supplied to the Chinese market. It is impossible to find such car variations in Russia, Europe, or the USA.
Ground Clearance of BMW X1 and AUDI Q3
When analyzing the ground clearance of BMW X1 and AUDI Q3, the model from the Bavarian automaker unequivocally becomes the leader. The X1 has a clearance size 15 mm larger, reaching 18.5 cm. The Audi has a similar parameter of only 17 cm.
Due to the ground clearance, the models were not able to achieve a significant difference in off-road capabilities. The reliability of driving in off-road conditions depends not only on ground clearance but also on the car's drive, the type of tires installed, and other factors.
Trunk Space
When comparing BMW X1 and AUDI Q3 based on the parameter of trunk space, it is also impossible to indicate a winner. The Bavarian model has a volume of 505 liters. With the rear seats folded, it can be increased to 1550 liters.
The trunk volume of the AUDI Q3 is 530 liters. However, with the seats up, it increases to 1525 liters, slightly less than the BMW X1.
An advantage of both cars is the flat floor after folding the seats. No sloping surfaces are formed. This allows for maintaining a useful volume.
Additional: Test Drive of Cadillac XT5 and BMW X3
Interior of BMW X1 and AUDI Q3
It is simply impossible to determine a clear leader between these crossovers when comparing the quality of the interior finish. Both cars belong to the premium segment. Inside, designers used only high-quality premium materials. Each element fits perfectly with the others, eliminating the occurrence of extraneous noises during driving.
The seats of the BMW X1 are characterized by advanced lateral support. They allow the driver to make sharp maneuvers without worrying about the back slipping slightly. All controls are positioned for maximum accessibility. Activating any control button will require a minimum of movements.
The choice of front seats in the AUDI Q3 is equally successful. The specific form of the seats immediately indicates certain speed characteristics of the car.
The driver's seat has various adjustments. The position can be adjusted in length, height, and tilt angle. However, in terms of driver comfort between the BMW X1 and AUDI Q3, a slight advantage can be given to the Bavarian. The issue with the Audi lies mainly in the sloping roof and short length. Tall individuals sitting in the rear seats will find it uncomfortable. They won't have to support their chin with their knees, but there will be some constraints in seating.
The BMW offers ample space for rear passengers. Sometimes, as an additional option, drivers are even offered to install a third row of seats. This alone speaks to the comfort and volume of the available free space.
Engines of BMW X1 and AUDI Q3
There are certain differences in the engine options between BMW X1 and AUDI Q3. The Bavarian crossover offers 5 different variations:
- 1.5-liter petrol engine with 136 horsepower.
- 2.0-liter petrol engine with 192 horsepower.
- 2.0-liter petrol engine with 231 horsepower.
- 2.0-liter diesel engine with 150 horsepower.
- 2.0-liter diesel engine with 190 horsepower.
The variability in engine selection at AUDI is slightly less. The company's engineers offer 4 different types of engines:
- 1.4-liter petrol engine with 150 horsepower.
- 2.0-liter petrol engine with 180 horsepower.
- 2.0-liter petrol engine with 220 horsepower.
- 2.0-liter diesel engine with 184 horsepower.
In the base configuration, the power of BMW is lower than that of its competitor. This allowed the manufacturers to reduce fuel consumption.
Technical Features
Drivers have various car variations to choose from. Both BMW X1 and AUDI Q3 are available with all-wheel drive or exclusively front-wheel drive. The latter models are less capable off-road but are cheaper and consume less fuel.
The crossovers are produced with both automatic and manual transmissions. If desired, the driver can add almost any available option.
Price of BMW X1 and AUDI Q3
The models are roughly in the same price category. The minimum selling price of the updated BMW X1 starts at 1.85 million rubles. For the top configuration, the driver will have to pay 2.9 million rubles.
The initial version of the AUDI Q3 is more expensive. The base model costs 1.91 million rubles. However, the maximum configuration of the car is cheaper than the top model of the BMW X1 by 350 thousand rubles.
Conclusions
It is impossible to determine a clear leader in the comparison between BMW X1 and AUDI Q3. Each car has its own advantages and disadvantages. And both brands have their staunch fans. On the road, BMW looks more dynamic, fast, and aggressive. AUDI is more serene. However, you can also participate in races with it.
